The phrase gluten-free beer covers two very different products, and the country on the label decides which one is even allowed to use those words. One is brewed from gluten-free grains such as millet, buckwheat, rice or sorghum, in a brewery that keeps barley and wheat out of the process. The other starts with the usual barley, and sometimes wheat or oats, then uses enzymes to break gluten down in the hope of finishing below 20 parts per million. In the United Kingdom, both can be sold as gluten-free beer if that 20 ppm line is met. In the United States, only the first kind may be labeled gluten-free.
Two current examples make the split concrete. Holidaily Brewing Co. in Golden, Colorado, is a dedicated gluten-free brewery, and we covered its arrival in Michigan on Oct. 28. Brew York’s new Judas Priest collaboration, the Hellion pale ale, is sold in the UK as gluten-free beer even though the shop lists barley, oats and wheat among the ingredients. That is not a typo. It is the UK rule doing something the U.S. rule will not.
Can a barley beer be sold as gluten-free beer?
In the United States, the answer is no. Alcohol labels sit with the Tax and Trade Bureau, which follows the Food and Drug Administration’s definition of “gluten-free.” Under TTB Ruling 2020-2, a wine, spirit or malt beverage may use “gluten-free,” “no gluten,” “free of gluten” or “without gluten” only if it would qualify under the FDA rule at 21 CFR 101.91. That rule does not allow a gluten-containing grain, including barley, wheat or rye, to be used in a food labeled gluten-free, even if the finished gluten number is under 20 ppm. A beer fermented from barley and then treated with enzymes may instead say it was “processed,” “treated” or “crafted” to remove gluten, but only with a mandatory qualifier: that it was fermented from grains containing gluten, that the gluten content cannot be verified, and that the product may contain gluten.
The FDA has been direct about why that disclaimer exists. In its rule on fermented and hydrolyzed foods, the agency said there is still no scientifically validated method that can quantify gluten in fermented or enzyme-treated beer the way it can in unfermented food. Studies have found gluten fragments, including some associated with celiac disease, in enzyme-treated beers that tested below the limit of standard ELISA kits. The 20 ppm line is a testing threshold, not a promise that every leftover peptide is gone. This is labeling law, not medical advice. Anyone with celiac disease or a gluten-related disorder should follow their clinician, and should not treat a “crafted to remove gluten” U.S. beer as the same thing as gluten-free beer.
UK and EU rules start from a different place. Retained Regulation (EU) No. 828/2014 allows a “gluten-free” claim on food that contains no more than 20 milligrams of gluten per kilogram as sold, and a “very low gluten” claim at no more than 100 mg/kg for foods made from gluten grains that have been specially processed to reduce gluten. A barley beer that tests at or below 20 ppm may therefore be sold as gluten-free beer in the UK. The cereal still has to be declared as an allergen, which is why Hellion can be labeled gluten free and still list barley, oats and wheat. Coeliac UK says both naturally gluten-free beer and gluten-removed beer may carry the gluten-free label if they meet that 20 ppm test, preferably by the R5 competitive ELISA method used for fermented drinks. Brew York does not post a lab result for Hellion on the product page, so we are describing the legal standard, not a certified number for that can.
If you are shopping in the United States, dedicated gluten-free breweries such as Holidaily are the ones allowed to put “gluten-free beer” on the package, because they brew from gluten-free ingredients and have to keep cross-contact below 20 ppm. Enzyme-treated barley beers sold here should not say gluten-free; look instead for the longer “crafted to remove gluten” language and its warning. If you are shopping in the UK, a gluten-free beer can be either of those recipes, and the ingredients list is the tell. Hellion is the barley-based kind. It is also a UK-only release, with no U.S. availability we could find, which keeps the two rulebooks from colliding on the same shelf.
BEERALIEN.COM | Reporting on Earth’s finest craft beers from a galaxy far, far away.
